Talk:Cave Dreamer: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
===[[User:Spblat|Spblat]]=== | |||
Not one of my favorites. Sound effects, dramatization. I just like it when he tells stories. - [[User:Spblat|Spblat]] ([[User talk:Spblat|talk]]) 17:19, 5 February 2005 | Not one of my favorites. Sound effects, dramatization. I just like it when he tells stories. - [[User:Spblat|Spblat]] ([[User talk:Spblat|talk]]) 17:19, 5 February 2005 | ||
---- | ---- | ||
=== [[User:Shiro|Shiro]] === | |||
This program is entertaining, but I recommend The Dictator instead. The strange thing is that a one hour edit of this material sounds quite promising. I love The Dictator - it is among my favorite programs - but the narrative has always felt a forced and unnatural. There are at least three major elements: the dictator, the dirt eater, and the circus performer. There's no obvious reason to combine all three in a single character, and I never understood the decision to do so. Oddly enough, this program maintains all three. We just lose some detail from each, and give up some great writing such as the ''why not kill civilians'' discussion. If anything, this shorter format makes the story seem less coherent. - [[User:Shiro|Shiro]] ([[User talk:Shiro|talk]]) 01:52, 16 May 2005 | This program is entertaining, but I recommend The Dictator instead. The strange thing is that a one hour edit of this material sounds quite promising. I love The Dictator - it is among my favorite programs - but the narrative has always felt a forced and unnatural. There are at least three major elements: the dictator, the dirt eater, and the circus performer. There's no obvious reason to combine all three in a single character, and I never understood the decision to do so. Oddly enough, this program maintains all three. We just lose some detail from each, and give up some great writing such as the ''why not kill civilians'' discussion. If anything, this shorter format makes the story seem less coherent. - [[User:Shiro|Shiro]] ([[User talk:Shiro|talk]]) 01:52, 16 May 2005 | ||
Latest revision as of 13:02, 26 March 2021
Spblat
Not one of my favorites. Sound effects, dramatization. I just like it when he tells stories. - Spblat (talk) 17:19, 5 February 2005
Shiro
This program is entertaining, but I recommend The Dictator instead. The strange thing is that a one hour edit of this material sounds quite promising. I love The Dictator - it is among my favorite programs - but the narrative has always felt a forced and unnatural. There are at least three major elements: the dictator, the dirt eater, and the circus performer. There's no obvious reason to combine all three in a single character, and I never understood the decision to do so. Oddly enough, this program maintains all three. We just lose some detail from each, and give up some great writing such as the why not kill civilians discussion. If anything, this shorter format makes the story seem less coherent. - Shiro (talk) 01:52, 16 May 2005
